Feminist Mommy vs. Babes in Toyland
May 28th, 2009 at 7:42 pm (Movies/ TV, Politics, The Kids, Uncategorized, YouTube Fun)
There’s a dozen or so movies that I can think of that I would always watch when they came on tv. Not that I planned it out and checked the tv guide or anything, the ones that are cyclical or seasonal that the basic tv stations would air every so often. Didn’t matter how many times I’d seen it or even if I owned it, it was a guilty pleasure thing that would suck me in and I’d watch while doing some task. Splash comes to mind and Swiss Family Robinson, pretty much any musical ever, and Babes in Toyland starring Annette Funicello and Frankie Avalon from 1961. It’s a musical of all the characters from Mother Goose’s book of rhymes and tales. The scene with the talking moving trees used to scare me but I’d still watch it. Mainly, I’d just watch the first half of the movie for my favorite part; a song called “I can’t do the Sum” by Annette Funicello. Remembering how much I enjoyed this movie, I knew Kosette would like it too.
Well, watching this particular scene, and hearing the lyrics to this song, I was appalled at its message. I have never been terrific at math (understatement of the century). At my tutor’s house, I was mortified that her 1st grader could do what I couldn’t at 4th grade. And a very sharp memory, that still pains me and probably would make my mom cringe if I refreshed her memory, was when I was in the car on the drive home from 6th grade, excited, because I’d finally figured out what I wanted to be —– a zoologist. And you want to know what my mom said dismissively, “You can’t do that, you suck at math.” Now I know, and I can recognize that my mom’s tone of voice, and technique, showed that she was using a bit of reverse psychology. But it backfired. Even though I protested, I did so weakly, because there was this little bitty part of me that just gave up hope, “Well, if my own MOM thinks that I’m bad at math, I really must be.” Completely unintentional on my mom’s part….it’s just one of those learning curves as a parent I guess. Something I’m going to try to avoid with my own kids. There’s a whole mess of other mistakes already made and waiting to be made. Sometimes I feel, I’ve been searching for a profession ever since.
So then I had a choice to make. Should I donate the movie to someone else because it doesn’t fit my feminist standards? Especially when I still sorta like it? I opted to keep it, as I have others, to use it as a prompt for discourse with my children about messages they’re getting. She’s going to ultimately come across stuff like this, does so on a daily basis. I want her to be able to recognize it for what it is. The movie is now in the category of “with adult supervision and dialogue ONLY”.
The total bummer…Don’t know why I never noticed it much before but most musicals are absolutely horrible in they’re gender messages. I have to completely suspend that part of my brain and stay in complete denial now, when I, and we, watch them. Like Twilight. Don’t think about it from a Feminist perspective, it’ll kill the books I so guiltily love….they are the ultimate guilty pleasure for me. When I was in college I took a Gender and Feminism in Film class. That would’ve made my perfect final paper – sexism and gender roles/identity in the American musical genre. Instead I did something based on all of the Alien films. Betcha didn’t know I liked those did you? They’re very different from Babes in Toyland and Beach Blanket Bingo side of me.
What do you think? I wish I could’ve found the lyrics somewhere. Looks like I’m going to have to sit down and write them out myself one day when I have all the extra time in the world – yeah right.






















